Skip to main content

Sherlocked: which interpretation of the great detective do you like the best?

 Today is Halloween, and what better time to write about Sherlock Holmes?



Sherlock made his literary debut in 1887, with the short story "A Study in Scarlet."  The author was Conan Doyle (later to become "Sir").  Tales appeared in print until 1927.  Mostly, the lore of Sherlock and Watson comes in the form of short stories, with only a smattering of novels, here and there, but oh those short stories captured the imagination of many throughout the 20th and 21st centuries. Dozens of plays, movies, and books have since been created, since the first publication of Doyle's detective's adventures, and absolutely everyone who has ever seen a film adaptation of Sherlock has their favorite actor who portrays him.  

It's kind of like who is your favorite James Bond?

Sean Connery, ye gods!

As for me? I have always been a purist about Sherlock Holmes, and while I love Basil Rathbone's interpretation, I would have to say that Jeremy Brett comes the closest to the spirit of Doyle's amateur detective.  My mother prefers Basil.  So did my father.  I like Basil as well, but I feel that the producers took too many liberties with the stories.  But as I said, I'm a purist.

Having stated that, I do enjoy watching Benedict Cumberbatch, and Martin Freeman, the latest interpretation of the dynamic duo.  But, then who wouldn't like watching these oh - so - attractive men?

😁


But, Dear Reader, would you be interested to know that Doyle's character inspired a lot the techniques of what eventually become forensic science? After all, when Doyle was first writing these stories, police were just beginning to realize that one could possibly identify criminals, using the shapes of ears, and later fingerprints.  But Sherlock used his magnifying glass to seek out different forms of proof, such as footprints, candles that shed no wax when and if they were moved, and the dog who didn't bark in the night. Today, we would call that circumstantial evidence, and yet there were the beginnings of forensic detection in those stories, which make the fictional detective so popular, over one hundred years after his first appearance.

There is a great documentary on this subject (Amazon) called "How Sherlock Changed the World"
if you're at all curious.  

As for myself, I try to watch some Sherlock at least every month or so, just to keep my hand in.  I love his use of logic, and his cold pragmatism--good vs. evil in the most interesting way.  Sherlock is not necessarily purely good, however, he is something of an enigma--an uneasy combination of the two.  And yet, there is something of the modern anti-hero in his character that strikes me as so terribly modern, which is why I believe his character still translates so well to the audience of the present. 

To put it succinctly, I shall celebrate this Halloween by watching "The Hound of the Baskervilles" with Jeremy Brett, and I will hope, Dear Reader, that you have a safe, happy, and spooky holiday!


And, what Halloween would be complete without this? :)



I believe in the Great Pumpkin, don't you?


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ladies and Gentlemen of the Jury...trying the Nazi bastard hierarchy....(2)

Every time I think about WW2, and its' aftermath, I think of this song by Dylan: Dylan lends gravitas to just about anything, don't you find?  And the sixties, when the song was written, were hard times, during which the 'hard rain' fell in the aftermath of World War II. And now back to our regularly scheduled broadcast, the Nurenberg trials. Now, let us further imagine that we had a chance to hold accountable some of the Nazis for the horrors seen at the concentration camps as they were liberated by the Allies   Additionally, the victors of World War II were hard pressed to understand in a cultural sense, both the German and Japanese Prisoners. Is difficult to ascertain how a society could have fallen under Hitler’s spell, but they did. It is also difficult to understand the Japanese response to external industrialisation. In their case, the code of Buchito made it possible for them to conquer so much of the Pacific Rim. As far as the German people are concerned, my ex...
Post a Comment
Read more

Some Justice at Nuremberg--what (probably) you never wanted to know about the post Nazi bastard WW2 trials, ONE.

  NOTE:  please accept my apology Dear Reader, for any who may have ventured forth on this blog of late.  It has been a long time since I last posted...my mother died, and I decided to live briefly on Venus.  But, I have returned, and hopefully you will still come along on some new adventures, even if they are bitter--as th is entry most certainly is.... I have written, in this blog, many warnings about  absolute power.  I have also dealt with the problems that come into focus, when individuals are seduced by that power, to the detriment of plebs.  So, there probably isn't that much left to say, excepting the fact that this seems to be an inexhaustible subject, due to the endless samples that continually present themselves. What I'd like to do in this entry, is to look a little bit at beginnings, and endings.  Hopefully, you might see a few parallels, and forgive me pointing them out along the way.  This is only my POV, however, please r...
Post a Comment
Read more

Just a Fourth of July wish for us all

 It's the time of corn on the cob, red white and blue flags, hot dogs, and beer.  And fireworks.  Of course fireworks. Overall, a time for Americans to celebrate the end of our eighteenth century revolt against the authority and overlord-ship of England. I hope that you will all enjoy your hamburgers and beer, as I know that you will all reflect for a second or two on the wonder of free speech and the right to assembly. Freedom (well, relative freedom) is a pretty nice thing. So, Dear Reader, enjoy your fourth.  If you're curious, check out any of these entertainments:  I watch them every single year and remember that without John Adams, we'd all be pretty screwed in this country: https://dai.ly/x2ngcau . 1776.  A campy but marvellous musical based on the broadway play. https://www.amazon.com/gp/video/detail/B00687PWQG/ref=atv_dp_share_cu_r A wonderful doc-series on the life and times of John and Abigail Adams. Try them out Dear Reader, and enjoy your day t...
Post a Comment
Read more